Sunday, February 2, 2014

So did Orange Range really rip off stuff?



1: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:48:46 ID:iwmcE9YO
http://flash.flop.jp/genomo/orangerange.html

これ聞いたけどイマイチパクリと思わないようなのばっかなんだが

もっと酷いパクリに慣れてるからやろか
I listened to this one but most of these don't sound ripped off to me.
Must be because I'm used to worse, more blatant rip-offs.



http://stat.ameba.jp/user_images/20091109/15/yamabiko141/f9/95/j/o0800061010301400157.jpg





5: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:50:24 ID:E0iZtqMV
以心伝心のドクターマリオはすぐっわかった
I immediately recognized Ishin Denshin's similarities to Dr. Mario

6: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:50:26 ID:mT8HjqvX
ドクターマリオはまじでドクターマリオにしか聞こえない
Dr. Mario seriously just sounds like Dr. Mario
8: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:50:52 ID:lhrGC+mw
アレンジやろ(震え声)
That's just called "arrangement" (trembling voice)
10: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:51:10 ID:jfICKhpN
ドクターマリオって逆にあれを歌にするの凄くないかw
Conversely, don't you actually think it's amazing that they turned that Dr. Mario music into a song? w
7: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:50:47 ID:T28inK39
今だったらそんな叩かれてなかった気がする
I don't think they'd be bashed as much if they came out in this generation
13: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:52:14 ID:Kx63d9hb
そもそもロコローションとかタイトルからしてわざとやっとるからね
そういうスタンスのバンドとしてきちんと評価されるべきだったのに馬鹿が大量に叩きはじめた
They were already copying on purpose, what with the title "Locolotion".
They were a band with that kind of stance and should've been recognized for that, but then tons of stupid people started bashing them left and right.

24: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:54:30 ID:j3H9E5X6
>>13
そういう方向で嫌われないようにするのも大事な事だからな
菅野よう子みたいに盗作しまくりな奴でもオタクの教祖になれば国内では何も言われないし
If they were taking that kind of stance, then it's also important for them to be more careful so people won't hate them.
Take a look at Yoko Kanno. She's been plagiarizing music all the time, but since she's like the religious leader of otakus, no one's even saying stuff about her.




34: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:56:49 ID:uvblpk9l
ロコローションはパクリというかサンプリング
ただ許可を得てなかっただけ
You can't call "Locolotion" plagiarism, that's more like "sampling".
They just didn't get permission.
15: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:52:47 ID:T+5pOr8h
目立ち過ぎたな。
They just stood out too much.
20: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:53:59 ID:jfICKhpN
パクリとは言えあんなキャッチーな曲作るのは才能やろなあ
It may be called plagiarizing, but I think they still have talent for being able to compose catchy songs like that
23: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:54:24 ID:gLpD5T29
アルバム聴くと評価変わるな
One's view of them will change once they get to listen to the album
26: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:54:51 ID:0Tn0MTB2
有名になるものってだいたいパクリ言われてる
Most of the things that become popular are being accused of plagiarizing something else
27: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:55:54 ID:Kx63d9hb
>>26
ビートルズですらパクリ言われるしな
Even the Beatles were accused of plagiarism
33: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:56:49 ID:PK9pI1yv
もう十分稼いだから自分たちの好きなこと出来て楽しそう
I think they're just enjoying their lives since they've already amassed quite an amount
35: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:56:50 ID:1hk9Wqtk
最近の邦楽が酷過ぎてオレンジレンジの再評価が始まっとる
It seems that Orange Range are being considered good again because of how horrible Japanese music is these days.
40: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:57:31 ID:uvblpk9l
>>35
あと10年もしたらAKBも曲自体は良かったとか言われてるよ
People will start talking about how good AKB's songs are in 10 years time
38: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:57:08 ID:AKbzyiXi
馬鹿にされとるけど普通にメロディーはいい模様
People make fun of them, but their melodies are actually quite nice

43: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:58:14 ID:+BOdbHI/
パクリ元から直接抗議来たらスタンス変えろよとは思う
I just think that they should change their stance once the guys they copied from directly file a complaint
45: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 00:59:02 ID:n+zr6GqB
パクってなんぼみたいな事言ってたしな
アレンジの範疇としては認められなかったのがアカンかったな
They did say that it's all about ripping off stuff.
Their downfall was that it wasn't categorized as "arrangements".
52: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:00:02 ID:G9kERhj5
サンプリングじゃなくて悪意あるパクリだから叩かれて当然
You can't call that sampling. It was clearly ripping off with malicious intent. Of course they'd be criticized for that.
54: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:00:13 ID:PkeDM5xc
パクリ云々以前にあんな下手な歌と演奏で何故あんなに持ち上げられたのか
But even before talking about plagiarism, why the heck were people praising them despite that bad singing and playing?
66: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:01:22 ID:Kx63d9hb
>>54
歌詞も下品だったな
それでゴールデンの歌番組でキャーキャー言われとったってのは今考えると謎やな
Even their lyrics were vulgar.
It really was a mystery how people went ga-ga over them during prime time programs.
68: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:01:49 ID:Dd6FPbsI
>>54
でもカラオケじゃ盛り上がったで
パクリと言うけどそのオリジナルを歌っても盛り上がらんで。
But karaoke sessions were really lively with their songs.
Even if you sing the original which they plagiarized, it wouldn't liven up the place that much.
55: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:00:18 ID:YXDuVO6g
ドクターまり男結構やったけど
なにをぱくってるか何も気付かないワイ
比較動画はめんどいからみない
I played quite a lot of Dr. Mario, but I never noticed what they copied from that.
The comparison videos too troublesome so I haven't watched it.
62: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:00:53 ID:TyiLt4TC
オレンジレンジの歌は好きだったな
メロディーが良かった
I used to like Orange Range's songs.
Their melodies were good.
63: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:01:12 ID:T+5pOr8h
ま、一時期の存在感は凄かったな。今や嘘のように消えたが
Their presence really was amazing at one point.
Now they've just disappeared, as if everything was a lie.
http://blog-imgs-60-origin.fc2.com/s/a/f/safarina/1052.jpg
81: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:03:39 ID:uvblpk9l
正直言って今また出だしのオレンジレンジ出てきても売れると思うよ
バンドやってる男ってジメジメしたのが多い中こいつらは爽やかだったもん
Honestly, I think Orange Range would still be popular if they came out now -- even if they were still in their early days.
There are a lot of dark and gloomy men who played in bands, but these guys were really pleasant.
94: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:07:23 ID:jsxX8/qg
勝手にパクって訴えられた挙句示談にして知れっとカバーの振りしてたからな
印象は最悪や
They ripped off, got charged, settled it out of court, and then suddenly said it was a cover.
That gave them the worst image.
98: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:07:53 ID:1Mew1CfD
タイトルまで似せてるのにパクリって言われたらたまらんよ
They even made the title sound like the original, so it's too much if you start calling them rip-offs
110: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:10:31 ID:Gqc+cmgW
>>98
最初に許可貰わんといかん
たいてい怒る
You need to ask for permission first.
Most would get mad.
107: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:09:48 ID:iZLOJUHS
パクリは置いといて耳に残るメロディとメッセージ性のない下手な声と音の面白さを追求した歌詞のインパクト、実は凄いグループやったんかもしれん
Rip-off aside, they left strong impacts with their memorable melodies and their lyrics without messages combined with the horrible singing voice and interesting sound. They must've actually been an amazing group, in a sense.
108: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:09:58 ID:xjnbk5mI
だいたいオレンジレンジってあれバンドなんか
DQNくさいラップ調ばっかだったしただの音楽グループかとばかり思ってたわ
Can you even consider Orange Range as a band?
I always thought they were just some musical group who sounded like delinquents rapping.
112: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:10:43 ID:G9kERhj5
ラップやってMC名乗っててHIP HOPの連中にもディスられてたな
They rapped and called themselves MCs, so even the hip-hop crowd dissed them
118: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:11:27 ID:uvblpk9l
音楽にマジになってる層からは嫌われるよな
薄っぺらくエンターテイメント性のみを追求してるもんな
People who are serious with music hate them.
They were only going for entertainment value with their cheapness.
130: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:12:55 ID:9SQyW9S4
>>118
つか中途半端な音楽の聞き方してるやつほど叩いてた印象
My impression is that the guys who listened to half-a$$ed music were the ones who bashed them
123: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:12:03 ID:HfqE1WeH
というかパクリなんてORANGE RANGEだけじゃないでしょ
音大出てるシンガーソングライターなんてほとんどいないのにあんなに何曲もいい曲作れるわけない
But it's not like ORANGE RANGE were the only group who plagiarized.
There are almost no singer/songwriters you hear of who came from music universities, yet look how some of the ones we have are been coming up with all these good songs one after another.
131: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:12:57 ID:ejCdUYli
>>123
そういうファンの開き直りが嫌われる原因の一つなんやろうな
And one more factor why these artists are hated is because of this sort of defiant attitude taken by fans
127: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:12:39 ID:7ZvQoj3v
コードは模倣していいけどメロディは駄目っていうが
どう違うかいまだに分からない
People say you can imitate the chord progression but not the melody, but I still don't get the difference up to now.
161: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:17:40 ID:+BOdbHI/
>>127
コードは今更独自の進行も糞もない感じやけどメロは独自のが作られ続けてるからなあ
There aren't anymore original chord progressions these days, but original melodies are constantly being composed
128: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:12:55 ID:OF81r7jW
最近の再評価する風潮嫌い
手のひら返しすぎやろ
I hate how they're being recognized again these days.
People are too fickle-minded.
154: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:17:07 ID:8icXNpjo
>>128
手のひら返しというより当時中学生やった奴らが2chするようになって評価してるだけやろ
I don't think that people are fickle minded.
I think that the Jr. high kids who liked them back then all grew up and started going to 2ch to praise them.
132: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:13:22 ID:T28inK39
同じパクリでも叩かれるのと叩かれないのは、キャラの差やからな
多分フリッパーズギターとかオザケンとかはレンジと同じ時代なら同じくらい叩かれてたと思う。キャラがうざいから
スピッツとかは結構パクリあるけどまぁ叩かれないのは、キャラがうざくないからやな
If there are different artists who plagiarize, the difference in their character must be what separates the ones who get criticized from the ones who don't. I think that The Flipper's Guitar and Kenji Ozawa would've been bashed as much if they came out during the same time as Range, since they've all got annoying characters.
Even Spitz has a lot of rip-offs, but they're not being criticized because, well, they're not annoying.

http://art62.photozou.jp/pub/318/2020318/photo/139026422_624.jpg
135: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:13:48 ID:hzV9iaed
オレンジレンジのキャッチーで耳に残る感じはすごいとおもう
ワンオクも人気かも知れんがキャッチー感がないから今の人気が去ったら忘れ去られそうや
I do find it amazing how Orange Range's songs are so catchy and memorable.
ONE OK may be popular now, but they're not that catchy, and once their populairty passes, I think people will forget about them.
137: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:14:12 ID:Gqc+cmgW
まぁパクリなんてそれこそビートルズの頃からあるからぎゃあぎゃあ騒いでもしゃあない
オレンジレンジのは露骨すぎだけど
Plagiarism has been around since the time of the Beatles so there's no more point in making noise about it. Orange Range was just too blatant. 
141: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:14:49 ID:pUXvmQIu
MUSIQに収録されてた曲は全部すきやったわ
I liked all the songs in their album MUSIQ

http://www.geocities.jp/ninaomba_safari_njema/orangerange.musiq.jpg
164: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:18:15 ID:4B/sucD8
>>141
わかる
中古で100円で投げ売りされてるから今度買おうかな
I get you.
Used copies are only being sold now for 100 yen so maybe I'll buy that.
142: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:15:02 ID:sOArOoap
結局売れてるから叩かれてるだけやで
嫉妬運命
They were popular, hence they were bashed.
Fate of those whom people become jealous of.
147: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:15:25 ID:uvblpk9l
馬鹿な若者が若さのみで突っ切る感じがいいんだけどな
メッセージ性も何もないのがいい
I did like how they didn't have any sort of messages in their songs, and it seemed like these youngsters tried to live life to the fullest during their youth.
151: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:16:32 ID:ejCdUYli
あんなに下手くそで売れるのは凄いんかもな
売れたバンドのなかで一番下手くそちゃうか
It's impressive how they became that popular despite being really technically bad.
Aren't they technically the worst band ever to become popular?
159: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:17:30 ID:uvblpk9l
>>151
それは絶対そうやな
ボーカルが壊滅的にヘタ
だからカラオケで歌いやすいのかも
Most likely so.
The vocals are just flat out horrible.
That's probably why their songs are easy to sing on karaoke.
155: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:17:07 ID:vd4XxIWo
売れる曲を作ろうと思ったらありきたりなコード進行になるからどれかには似た曲にはなるんだよな
そこを暗黙の了解でやってたのに本人たちがパクってますなんて公に言っちゃったから音楽業界から嫌われたんだろう
When you try to make a song that sells, you'd eventually wind up with similar chord progressions so everything sounds the same. That was like an unwritten law within the music industry, but these guys went out in the open and said "We copy stuff", which is probably why they're hated.
156: 風吹けば名無し 2013/10/21 01:17:09 ID:6186AIB+
オレンジレンジは酷かったで
ただ今のメインストリームの音楽シーンが壊滅的状況だからこんなんでも回顧されるだけ
Orange Range was horrible.
It's just that the current mainstream music scene is in such a catastrophic state, that even a band like this is being reminisced.




Original Thread
http://hayabusa.2ch.net/test/read.cgi/livejupiter/1382284126/

Shop for Orange Range-related items on CDJapan
Shop for Orange Range-related items on YESASIA

Shop the Orange Range store on AMAZON
  

No comments:

Post a Comment